Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-09-012
Appeal Relative to:
(Z4 Corp vs. DOE) re: GPSS IFB 008-2009 (Re-Bid) Oceanview Middle School Gymnasium Repairs
Appellant:
Z4 Corporation
Purchasing Agency:
- Department of Education
Appeal Received:
Thursday, November 12, 2009 - 4:00pm
Appeal Status:
- Decision
Type of Appeal:
- Method of Solicitation or Award
Procurement Record Due:
Friday, November 20, 2009 - 5:00pm
Procurement Record Filed:
Friday, November 20, 2009 - 3:30pm
Agency Report Due:
Monday, November 30, 2009 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Filed:
Wednesday, December 9, 2009 - 4:45pm
Comments On Agency Report Due:
Tuesday, December 29, 2009 - 5:00pm
Comments on Agency Report Filed:
Tuesday, December 29, 2009 - 4:15pm
Pre-Hearing:
Friday, January 22, 2010 - 9:00am
Tentative Hearing Date:
Monday, February 22, 2010 - 9:00am
Decision Due:
Wednesday, May 5, 2010 - 5:00pm
Decision Filed:
Wednesday, May 5, 2010 - 5:00pm
Disposition Filed:
Monday, July 26, 2010 - 11:15am
Disposition:
Stipulation and Order
Remarks:
UPDATE: On July 26, 2010, the Public Auditor released the Stipulation and Order signed by DOE, Z4 and OPA. The agreement may be viewed in its entirety on this website.
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Notice of Appeal - Part 1
Download 09-012_Notice_of_Appeal.pdf (249.82 KB) - PDF Notice of Appeal - Part 2
Download 09-012_Notice_of_Appeal_Part_2.pdf (2.46 MB) - PDF DECISION
https://opaguam.org 09-012 DECISION 05-05-10 0.pdf
Download 09-012_DECISION_05-05-10.pdf (727.76 KB) Download 09-012_DECISION_05-05-10.pdf (727.76 KB) - PDF Notice of Receipt of Appeal
Download 09-012_Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.PDF (3.75 MB) - PDF Audio Record: 01/22/10 Pre-Hearing Conference
(26.55 MB ) - WAV
Agency Report - Table of Contents and Executive Summary (Note: Voluminous report. Contact Anne Camacho at 475-0390 x 291 to schedule an appointment to review in its entirety.)
Download DOC048.PDF (336.26 KB) - PDF Procurement Record - Table of Contents (Note: Voluminous report. Contact Anne Camacho at 475-0390 x 219 to schedule an appointment to review in its entirety.)
Download 09-012_Submission_of_Procurement_Record.pdf (668.58 KB) - PDF Comments on Agency Report
Download 09-012_Comments_on_Agency_Report.pdf (885.3 KB) - PDF Declaration of Pete M. Valencia
Download 09-012_Declaration_of_Pete_M_Valencia.pdf (155.34 KB) - PDF Notice of Pre-Hearing Conference
Download 09-012_Notice_of_Pre-Hearing_Conference.pdf (504.19 KB) - PDF Notice of Hearing re Appellant's Appeal
Download 09-012_Notice_of_Pre-Hearing_Conference.pdf (504.19 KB) - PDF Scheduling Order Re Hearing For Appellant's Appeal
Entry of Appearance - Laura Mooney
Download 09-012_Entry_of_Appearance_Laura_Mooney.pdf (54.8 KB) - PDF Motion to Dismiss
Download 09-012_Motion_to_Dismiss.pdf (70.67 KB) - PDF Memorandum in Support of Appellee's Motion GSA/GDOE to Dismiss
Appellee DOE's Submission of Witness and Exhibit Lists
Download 09-012_Appellee_DOE_Witness_and_Exhibit_Lists.pdf (270.95 KB) - PDF Appellee DOE's Hearing Brief
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Appellee DOE Hearing Brief 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Appellee_DOE_Hearing_Brief.pdf (808.55 KB) Download 09-012_Appellee_DOE_Hearing_Brief.pdf (808.55 KB) - PDF Z4 Corporation's Witness List
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Z4 Corp Witness List 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Witness_List.pdf (67.14 KB) Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Witness_List.pdf (67.14 KB) - PDF Z4 Corporation's Statement of the Issues
Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Statement_of_Issues.pdf (67.56 KB) - PDF Z4 Corporation's Hearing Brief
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Z4 Corp Hearing Brief 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Hearing_Brief.pdf (540.15 KB) Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Hearing_Brief.pdf (540.15 KB) - PDF Z4 Corporation's Exhibit List
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Z4 Corp Exhibit List 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Exhibit_List.pdf (196.22 KB) Download 09-012_Z4_Corp_Exhibit_List.pdf (196.22 KB) - PDF Errata (Z4's Correction of Exhibit Index)
Download 09-012_Errata.pdf (178.79 KB) - PDF Opposition to Appellee's Motion to Dismiss
Download 09-012_Opposition_to_Appellee's_Motion_to_Dismiss.pdf (813.52 KB) - PDF Motion to Present GSA Witnesses Via Teleconferencing or on the Alternative to Continue the Hearing
Order Granting DOE's Motion to Recess Hearing
Download 09-012_Order_Granting_DOE's_Motion_to_Recess_Hearing.pdf (192.46 KB) - PDF Submission of DOE Supplemental Documents
Download 09-012_Submission_of_DOE's_Supplemen_tal_Documents.pdf (252.63 KB) - PDF DOE's CIP Bond Funding Authorization and the DPW-GPSS Relationship
Order Granting Appellant's Motion to Reschedule Hearing Time
Submission of DOE's Supplemental Document
Download 09-012_Submission_of_DOE's_Supplemental_Document.pdf (243.41 KB) - PDF Declaration of Pete M. Valencia 6/14/10
Download 09-012_Declaration_of_Pete_M_Valencia_06-14-10.pdf (98.34 KB) - PDF Statement of Costs and Reasonable Profit and Motion for Attorneys' Fees as Costs
DOE's Response to Z4's Statement of Costs and Reasonable Profit and Z4's Motion for Attorney's Fees and Costs
Notice of Hearing and Scheduling Order for Appellant's Statement of Costs, Reasonable Profits, and Motion for Attorney's Fees as Costs
Order Denying Appellant's Motion to Reschedule Hearing and Denying Purchasing Agency's Motions to Extend Time to File Opposition
Appellee DOE's Submission of Exhibit List for July 19 Hearing - Part 1
Download 09-012_Appellee_DOE's_Exhibit_List.pdf (1.47 MB) - PDF DOE's Exhibit List for July 19 Hearing - Part 2
Download 09-012_DOE's_Exhibit_List_Part_2.pdf (1.98 MB) - PDF DOE's Witness List for July 19 Hearing
Z4's Reply in Support of Its Statement of Costs and Reasonable Profit and Motion for Attorney's Fees and Costs
Z4's Exhibit List for July 19 Hearing
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Z4 Appellant%27s Exhibit List 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Z4_Appellant's_Exhibit_List.pdf (895.01 KB) Download 09-012_Z4_Appellant's_Exhibit_List.pdf (895.01 KB) - PDF Z4's Witness List
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Z4%27s Witness List 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Z4's_Witness_List.pdf (31.64 KB) Download 09-012_Z4's_Witness_List.pdf (31.64 KB) - PDF DOE's Submittal of Additional Witness
Download 09-012_DOE's_Submittal_of_Additional_Witness.pdf (26.53 KB) - PDF Z4's Objection to DOE's Submittal of Additional Witness and Motion to Strike
Objection to Subpoena Duces Tecum
Download 09-012_Objection_to_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum.pdf (113.74 KB) - PDF Erratum
Download 09-012_Erratum.pdf (31.88 KB) - PDF Request for Clarification as to the OPA's Scheduling of a Hearing Post the Final Appealable Order
Submission of Supplemental Document
Download 09-012_Submission_of_Supplemental_Document.pdf (75.06 KB) - PDF Stipulation and Order
https://opaguam.org 09-012 Stipulation and Order 0.pdf
Download 09-012_Stipulation_and_Order.pdf (79.23 KB) Download 09-012_Stipulation_and_Order.pdf (79.23 KB) - PDF 
