Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-23-002
Appeal Relative to:
Management & Infrastructure Support Services to GIAA's Baggage Conveyance Systems
Appellant:
Johndel International, Inc. dba. JMI-Edison
Purchasing Agency:
- Guam International Airport Authority
Appeal Received:
Monday, April 10, 2023 - 11:04am
Appeal Status:
- Decision
Type of Appeal:
- Decision on Protest of Method, Solicitation or Award
Procurement Record Due:
Tuesday, April 18, 2023 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Due:
Tuesday, April 25, 2023 - 5:00pm
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Decision - December 18, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 decision final.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_decision_final.pdf (328.16 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_decision_final.pdf (328.16 KB) - PDF GIAA's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law - November 17, 2023
Menzie's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law - November 17, 2023
Appellant's [Proposed] Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law - November 17, 2023
Purchasing Agency's Submission of of Exhibit for Supplemental Brief - October 27, 2028
Purchasing Agency's Supplemental Brief - October 26, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_purchasing_agencys_supplemental_brief.pdf (259.46 KB) - PDF Interested Party Menzies Aviation's Supplemental Brief on Emergency Procurement - October 26, 2023
Appellant's Brief on Emergency Procurement - October 26, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_appellants_brief_on_emergency_procurement.pdf (610.3 KB) - PDF Formal Hearing - October 12, 2023 (pt. 1)
Download Formal Hearing - October 12, 2023 (pt. 1) (53.27 MB) - MP3 Formal Hearing - October 12, 2023 (pt. 2)
Download Formal Hearing - October 12, 2023 (pt. 2) (46.43 MB) - MP3 Interested Party Menzies Aviation's Amended Exhibit List - October 5, 2023
Interested Party Menzies Aviation's Amended Witness List - October 5, 2023
Interested Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation's Exhibit “c” in .m4a format - October 5, 2023
Third Order After Hearing - September 14, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_third_order_after_hearing.pdf (132.75 KB) - PDF Second Amended Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - September 14, 2023
Status Hearing - September 14, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_september_14_2023_status_hearing.m4a (10.22 MB) - M4A Notice of Status Hearing - September 12, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_status_hearing_3.pdf (133.88 KB) - PDF Amended Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - August 15, 2023
Status Hearing - August 14, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_august_14_2023_status_hearing.m4a (8.14 MB) - M4A Notice of Status Hearing - August 7, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_status_hearing_2.pdf (133.75 KB) - PDF Status Hearing - August 7, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002-status-hearing.mp3 (4.61 MB) - MP3 Appellant's Hearing Brief - August 4, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_appellants_hearing_brief.pdf (475.66 KB) - PDF Hearing Brief of Interested Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation - August 4, 2023
Hearing Brief (Purchasing Agency) - August 4, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_hearing_brief_purchasing_agency.pdf (336.06 KB) - PDF Appellant's Exhibit List - August 1, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_appellants_exhibit_list.pdf (141.85 KB) - PDF Appellant's Witness List - August 1, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_appellants_witness_list.pdf (137.15 KB) - PDF GIAA's Witness List - August 1, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 giaas witness list.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_giaas_witness_list.pdf (217.92 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_giaas_witness_list.pdf (217.92 KB) - PDF GIAA's Exhibit List - August 1, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 giaas exhibit list.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_giaas_exhibit_list.pdf (228.59 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_giaas_exhibit_list.pdf (228.59 KB) - PDF Interested Party Menzies Aviation's Witness List - July 31, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_interest_party_menzies_aviations_witness_list.pdf (251.88 KB) - PDF Interested Party Menzies Aviation's Exhibit List - July 31, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_interest_party_menzies_aviations_exhibit_list.pdf (915.94 KB) - PDF Notice of Status Hearing - July 31, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_status_hearing.pdf (133.81 KB) - PDF Decision on Purchasing Agency's Motion to Dismiss; Interested Party's Motion to Dismiss and Motion for Summary Judgment - July 27, 2023
Motion Hearing - July 7, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_july_7_2023_motion_hearing.m4a (48.82 MB) - M4A (Corrected) Decision on Purchasing Agency's Objection to Hearing Officer and Motion to Appoint Alternate Hearing Officer - July 3, 2023
Decision on Purchasing Agency's Objection to Hearing Officer and Motion to Appoint Alternate Hearing Officer - June 30, 2023
Decision on Purchasing Agency's Objection to Hearing Officer and Motion to Appoint Alternate Hearing Officer - June 30, 2023
Second Order After Hearing - June 29, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_second_order_after_hearing.pdf (231.16 KB) - PDF Motion Hearing Continuation - January 28, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_june_28_2023_motion_hearing.m4a (32.76 MB) - M4A Objection to Hearing Officer and Motion to Appoint Alternative Hearing Officer - June 23, 2023
Order After Hearing - June 20, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 order after hearing.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_order_after_hearing.pdf (231.51 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_order_after_hearing.pdf (231.51 KB) - PDF Motion Hearing - June 20, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_june_20_2023_motion_hearing.m4a (13.52 MB) - M4A Reply RE GIAA Motion to Dismiss - June 13, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_reply_re_giaa_motion_to_dismiss.pdf (246.81 KB) - PDF Interested Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation's Reply in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment - June 13, 2023
Order Appointing Hearing Officer - June 13, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_order_appointing_hearing_officer.pdf (152.88 KB) - PDF Opposition to GIAA Motion to Dismiss - June 6, 2023
Omnibus Opposition to Interested Party Aircraft Services, Inc. DBA Menzies Aviation's 1. Motion to Dismiss and 2. Motion for Summary Judgment - June 6, 2023
Menzies Opposition to the JMI Motion for Appointment of Alternate Administrative Hearing Officer or in the Alternative an Order Directing the Superior Court to Hear this Matter - June 6, 2023
Interested Party Aircraft Service Joinder to GIAA Motion to Dismiss - June 6, 2023
Amended Scheduling Order - May 31, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_amended_scheduling_order.pdf (235.67 KB) - PDF Interested Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation Motion for Summary Judgment - May 19, 2023
Interested Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation Motion to Dismiss - May 19, 2023
Motion for Appointment of Alternate Administrative Hearing Officer or in the Alternative an Order Directing the Superior Court to Hear this Matter - May 19, 2023
Declaration of Joseph C. Razzano - May 19, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_declaration_of_joseph_c._razzano.pdf (906.67 KB) - PDF Motion to Dismiss - May 19, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 motion to dismiss.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_motion_to_dismiss.pdf (262.53 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_motion_to_dismiss.pdf (262.53 KB) - PDF Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - May 17, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_hearing_re_appellants_appeal.pdf (235.65 KB) - PDF Scheduling Order - May 17, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 scheduling order.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_scheduling_order.pdf (239.59 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_scheduling_order.pdf (239.59 KB) - PDF Pre-Hearing Conference - May 17, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_pre-hearing_conference.m4a (7.7 MB) - M4A Rebuttal to JMI's Comment's on Agency Report - May 12, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_rebuttal_to_jmis_comments_on_agency_report.pdf (537.33 KB) - PDF Notice of Pre-Hearing Conference and Motion Filing Deadline - May 8, 2023
Comments on Agency Report - May 5, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_comments_on_the_agency_report.pdf (1.51 MB) - PDF Comments of Interest Party Aircraft Service International, Inc. dba Menzies Aviation - May 5, 2023
Agency Statement - April 25, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 agency statement.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_agency_statement.pdf (278.51 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_agency_statement.pdf (278.51 KB) - PDF Agency Report - April 25, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 agency report.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_agency_report.pdf (511.29 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_agency_report.pdf (511.29 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance and Request for Notice - April 25, 2023
Entry of Appearance (Arriola Law Firm) - august 18, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 entry of appearance.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_entry_of_appearance.pdf (193.35 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_entry_of_appearance.pdf (193.35 KB) - PDF Hearing Request - April 18, 2023
https://opaguam.org opa-pa-23-002 hearing request.pdf
Download opa-pa-23-002_hearing_request.pdf (192.95 KB) Download opa-pa-23-002_hearing_request.pdf (192.95 KB) - PDF Declaration RE Court Action - April 18, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_declaration_re_court_action.pdf (196.89 KB) - PDF Notice of Contractor Awarded Contract - April 18, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_contractor_awarded_contract.pdf (195.32 KB) - PDF Submission of Procurement Record (TOC Only - Large document - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at jhernandez@guamopa.com to view)
Download opa-pa-23-002_submission_of_procurement_record_cover.pdf (250.64 KB) - PDF Notice of Receipt of Appeal - April 11, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_receipt_of_appeal.pdf (592.57 KB) - PDF Notice of Appeal - April 10, 2023
Download opa-pa-23-002_notice_of_appeal.pdf (3.25 MB) - PDF 
